Saturday, March 23, 2024

How Do You File A Civil Suit Against The Police

Don't Miss

How Do I File A Police Misconduct Lawsuit

A Civil Rights Case Against the Police From Start to Finish

Lawsuits for police abuse include claims for violations of both federal and state laws. Many suits are filed in federal courts due to constitutional violations and civil rights violations. These include federal violations of:

  • 42 U.S.C. § 1983 which states that peace officers who subject any U.S. resident to the deprivation of any rights, privileges, or immunities secured by the Constitution and laws may be held civilly liable for those injuries.
  • Fourth Amendment prohibiting excessive and unreasonable force as well as the denial of necessary medical care when the need for treatment was known.

State and local municipality claims are made for assault and battery, substandard training, and inadequate policies. Many state allegations are similar to the federal violations but are based upon Michigan laws and statutes.

To successfully prove a police misconduct civil lawsuit, the evidence must establish that the force used exceeded the level necessary for the purpose it was used.

This standard can be established by the use of an expert witness, who is typically a former chief law enforcement officer. Ultimately, it is up to a jury to decide if the officer and department should be liable for the allegations of misconduct.

Recommended Reading: How To Become A Mounted Police Officer

How Will A Police

Typically, we do not want to bring the civil claims regarding police misconduct or brutality until the criminal case is resolved.

The primary reason for that is there is a U.S. Supreme Court case called Heck v. Humphrey that holds that if the resolution of the criminal case will necessarily decide the issue of whether force was excessive, then you cant even pursue that civil case. If you want to bring a claim for excessive force against a police officer and you are charged with a crime of violence, the crime of violence with which you are charged could preclude the use of force you claim is excessive from being found by a court to be excessive. If you wind up pleading guilty or no contest to that criminal charge, or are convicted of it by a jury, your civil claim is automatically going to be extinguished.

What we will often recommend to our clients, as long as there is time before the statute of limitations runs out, is to work with their criminal-defense attorney to resolve whatever it is that they are being charged with and then worry about a civil claim. In the meantime, we can try to quietly investigate what happened. We do not want to draw too much attention to the fact that there may be a civil claim coming. Because unscrupulous prosecutors will sometimes double down, or insist on a release of civil liability before they will drop charges.

Related Practice Areas

What Is The Petito Family Claiming In Their Lawsuit

Gabbys parents have retained the Parker and McConkie law firm in Utah to handle the case. The firm in 2020 successfully represented the family of Lauren McCluskey, a 21-year-old University of Utah student who repeatedly asked for help from campus police before a 37-year-old man shot her outside her dorm in 2018. That case resulted in a $13.5 million settlement with the school.

In the lawsuit against Moab police, attorneys shared images of Gabby from the officers body camera footage and recapped the statement she made.

For one, Gabby was heard telling the officers, He, like grabbed me with his nail and I guess thats why it looksdefinitely I was cut right here because I can feel it. When I touch it, it burns.

Screenshot from body camera footage showing Gabby Petito describe an altercation between her and Brian Laundrie.

When asked about marks on her skin, she also told the officer Brian grabbed her arm.

In the wrongful death lawsuit, attorneys circled an area where marks were left on Gabby Petitos arm, they said. The original image was captured on Moab City police body camera footage.

An additional photo taken at the time, which has not yet been released publicly, showed a close-up view of Gabbys face where blood is smeared on her cheek and left eye, according to the lawsuit. The photo shows that Gabbys face was grabbed across her nose and mouth, potentially restricting her airway.

Also Check: How Many Police Officers In Chicago

About The Civil Rights Division

We protect your rights through:

Enforcement

We sue or prosecute individuals and organizations who violate civil rights laws.

You can help us do this work by reporting a possible civil rights violation through our online form.

Education

We help the entire federal government work together to enforce these laws.

Our teams work with other agencies to promote a consistent approach to civil rights laws.

You May Like: How To Apply To A Police Department

Can Evidence Found Through The Misconduct Be Excluded From Court

Family of Akron teen who died in police custody files civil lawsuit ...

Victims in police misconduct cases can find themselves facing a criminal charge. Evidence may have been obtained by violating the suspects civil rights. The defense can bring a suppression motion asking that this evidence be excluded from trial. Without the evidence obtained through the misconduct, the prosecutor may have little else to use.

Misconduct victims can also file a civil rights lawsuit under 42 U.S.C. Section 1983

Read Also: Can Police Help Me Unlock My Car

Complaints Not In Our Jurisdiction:

When the CCRB receives a complaint that falls outside of its jurisdiction, it refers the complaint to the appropriate agency. For example, if your complaint is about police corruption or neglect of duty, the CCRB would send it to the Internal Affairs Bureau or the Office of the Chief of Department respectively both are part of the police department.

What Is Police Abuse

Police abuse involves any type of misconduct or misrepresentation of power. Also called abuse of power, this encompasses the many ways that officers can take advantage of their powerful position in our society. Some examples of police abuse involve officers who treat citizens with unwarranted brutality, engage in corrupt acts that put innocent citizens lives at stake, or shoot people in response to little or no provocation.

Recommended Reading: What Happens When You File A Police Report For Theft

Also Check: Are Police Reports Public Record In Tennessee

How Do I File A Civil Suit Against The Police

Submitted:Category:

The best way to do it is to contact a local lawyer to draft and file a lawsuit. If you want to do it yourself, you could try this website which gives general instructions about how to write a :

However, no general internet resource is sufficient to tell you how to draft a lawsuit. The best way to learn is to go to law school and then spend several years working in a law firm. Every lawsuit is different and you need to write and file a complaint that is specifically applicable to your lawsuit.

The best way to achieve that is to hire a lawyer to do it for you.

As I mentioned earlier, in order to do this you will need to hire a local attorney, because filing a lawsuit is not a service we can provide through this website. However, I would be happy to assist you in connecting with a local attorney. The good news is that hiring an attorney for this type of work will not cost you anything.

Your first step should be to get a free consultation from a local attorney in your area and have him or her take this case on a contingency basis .

Be sure to create a timeline of events and organize your evidence before your consultation so that you will be prepared to explain your case to the attorney clearly and effectively.

You can find local attorneys for free by doing a search for your zip code and filtering for personal injury attorneys and litigation attorneys here:

What Is A False Arrest

Two former Cincinnati police officers file civil lawsuit against city

An arrest is an intentional deprivation of someones freedom of movement. That deprivation compels the person to stay or go somewhere, against his will.3

An arrest can be a false arrest if the peace officer had no legal authority to make it. False arrests violate the victims Fourth Amendment rights. They are also known as false imprisonments. They can happen when:

  • police make an arrest without a warrant or probable cause, or
  • police use an invalid arrest warrant to make an arrest.

Some victims are arrested without a warrant. In these cases, the police officer has to show he or she had probable cause.4 This requires showing there was reasonable cause to believe the person arrested had committed either:

  • any crime in the officers presence.5

Other arrests happen pursuant to a warrant. These can still be false arrests if the warrant was invalid.

Even if the warrant was invalid, though, the arrest can be legal if the officer acted in good faith.6

Police commit misconduct when they use excessive force during an arrest.

Don’t Miss: How To Become A Police Officer In Bakersfield Ca

New York City Violation Of Civil Rights & Police Brutality Lawyer

You have certain rights that cannot be infringed. Just because someone is a police officer or represents the state doesnt mean that your rights dont matter.

When the police cross a line, they must be held accountable. If your civil rights have been violated or if youve been the victim of police brutality in New York City, you might be entitled to compensation.

The experienced NYC civil rights and police brutality lawyers at Mirman, Markovits & Landau, P.C. will help you fight to hold the city accountable. In the process, we will demand that you are paid a substantial monetary award for your injuries and suffering. With more than 200 combined years of experience and $1 Billion recovered, you know that we mean business and will work hard to get the job done.

You probably have a lot of questions. Thats why our NYC law firm offers a free consultation. Give us a call to schedule yours today. When you sit down with our compassionate team, we can review your case and provide some preliminary legal advice to help you decide whats next.

Representing All Victims Of Civil Rights Violations And Police Brutality In Nyc

At Mirman, Markovits & Landau, P.C., we know that any violation of your civil rights can have dire consequences for years to come. Our NYC police misconduct lawyers will work tirelessly to hold the city, police department, correctional officers, and any other liable parties responsible for the harm youve endured. We represent clients in all civil rights violations and police brutality cases, including:

  • Killing dogs without justification
  • Wrongful death, and more.

Our law firm knows that this is probably a very difficult time for you. We want to make things as easy as we can. Thats why well handle the details of your case from start to finish. Well investigate, interview, research, examine, consult, communicate, and negotiate. If necessary, well litigate. That way, you can focus on recovering from the incredibly traumatic experience youve just had. Give us a call today to schedule a free case assessment and learn more.

Recommended Reading: How To Become A Police Detective In California

Damages May Be Available For Victims Of Police Brutality In Nyc

Whether youve been physically assaulted by a cop or unlawfully arrested because you were racially profiled, the trauma of that can affect you for the rest of your life. New York City must be held fully accountable for the unlawful and harmful actions of those who represent it. You can accomplish this by filing a personal injury lawsuit and demanding an award of monetary damages.

Compensation could include money for:

  • Medical bills and expenses
  • Disability and/or reduced earning capacity
  • Emotional distress, including PTSD and depression
  • Disfigurement and scarring
  • Loss of enjoyment of life, and more.

If a loved one was killed because of an act of police brutality, you may also be entitled to a financial award. Our NYC police brutality attorneys can help you file a wrongful death claim against the city and fight to maximize your recovery.

Understanding The Concept Of Qualified Immunity

False Arrest NY

Anyone who is considering the idea of suing a police department must understand how qualified immunity works in New York. This is a legal concept that has to do with the ability to take legal action against police officers or even the police department in general. Simply put, qualified immunity is intended to prevent the filing of civil suits against public servants from being sued in response to carrying out their assigned duties.

This does not mean that civil suits are not possible. If there’s evidence that the public servant violated constitutional or statutory rights under the guise of carrying out his or her duties, a suit may be filed. This is a partial answer to the question of can you sue a police department for not doing their job since it would entail the failure to work within the limits of the law.

In 2021, the New York City Council took steps to limit qualified immunity. That is, there is more latitude for taking legal action if the police officer in question failed to perform his or her duties responsibly and that failure led to some sort of harm. So can I sue the police for not investigating or taking actions that hampered the investigation? It’s possible. Consulting with lawyers that sue police departments will provide you with the answers that you seek.

Recommended Reading: What Education Is Needed To Be A Police Officer

Proofs In Civil Lawsuits

When you sue a police department or police officer, the burden of proof is not as difficult as it is in a criminal case. For example, the prosecution has to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt in a criminal case. If the jury does not believe that the prosecution has met that burden of proof, the defendant is acquitted of the crime.

In a civil case, the plaintiff only has to prove that it is more likely than not that the defendant is liable for the incident. This means that if the plaintiff provides convincing evidence, the police department or police officer can be held liable for the incident.

Keep in mind: civil lawsuits can be complex. You should seek legal counsel if you are planning to file a civil lawsuit.

Payments For Excessive Force False Arrests On The Rise

There are many different grounds on which civil rights violations and police brutality lawsuits can be based. Many focus on allegations of excessive force and false arrests. Not only are the number of lawsuits alleging these types of police misconduct on the rise, but so are the payouts. Years ago, the city paid $48 million to settle these claims. That figure has more than doubled in the decade since. Between 2017 and 2018, NYC allocated $108 million to settle excessive force and false arrest lawsuits.

Recommended Reading: How To Report Police Harassment

Complaints Filed Prior To October 19 2009

Complaints filed prior to October 19, 2009 were made to the Ontario Civilian Commission on Police Services. The Commission will continue to deal with these complaints until they are concluded. Although current complaints will be made to the OIPRD, if you wish to file a complaint for events occurring before October 19, 2009, you must file with the Commission or with the chief of police of the police service involved. If you file with the Commission, it will forward your complaint to the chief of police of the police service involved for review and investigation.

When Police Can Help And When It Becomes A Civil Suit

Lawsuit: CTA supervisor arrested while trying to file complaint against CPD officer

You have probably heard the terms criminal and civil law before, but you may not understand the difference between them. Law enforcement agencies handle criminal cases, where the government files a complaint against the defendant, but the government doesnt file civil suits. Private citizens file civil suits against another person or a corporation. In a civil case, the plaintiff alleges that the defendant did something to harm them.

Can police enforce civil law or otherwise help with civil matters? Understanding when police can step in can clear up lots of confusion related to civil vs. criminal issues.

Also Check: Can You Access Police Reports Online

Can I Sue The Police For Excessive Force

By Steven J. Ellison, Esq. | Reviewed by Joseph Fawbush, Esq. | Last updated October 19, 2021

Yes, but you face an uphill battle. You can sue the police officers themselves who used excessive force. In some situations, you can sue the law enforcement officers’ supervisor for their subordinate’s conduct. And you also may be able to bring a claim against the municipality itself if it has a policy or custom that caused the use of excessive force. But civil rights cases involving police brutality or other police misconduct can be very complicated and hard to win.

How To File A Civil Rights Violation Complaint

Civil rights violations have been very much in the news in the last several years as more and more citizens have stood up for themselves and pushed back against those trying to deprive them of their rights under the law. Civil rights are more than a promise, they are a legal guarantee of fair and equal treatment free of discrimination and they apply to many aspects of our lives as Americans, including in housing, in education, in employment and in public accommodation. If you feel that your civil rights have been violated, there are several actions that you can take, including filing a civil rights violation complaint with the government or filing a lawsuit against the parties responsible.

Your first step is to determine whether your rights have been violated. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, there are many different categories of rights that are protected and that may be violated, including:

  • Religious freedom

Don’t Miss: How To Prepare To Become A Police Officer

More articles

Popular Articles