Wednesday, February 1, 2023

Is Lying To The Police A Crime

Don't Miss

How Do You Beat An Obstruction Charge

Is it a crime to lie to police? (Vehicle Code 31)

How to Beat an Obstruction Charge

  • Showing that the conduct was not illegal or unlawful.
  • Proving that the actions were protected under the First Amendment, such as free speech and the right to peacefully assemble.
  • Demonstrating that the conduct did not hinder a police officer in carrying out his or her duties.
  • Is It A Crime To Lie To A Police Officer In New Jersey

    Talking to police or criminal investigators can be a nerve-wracking experience. Desperate to end the encounter, you give the officer a fake name, or show a fake ID. Maybe you exaggerate your knowledge of certain information, or fudge the facts about another persons suspected criminal activity. It may feel tempting to end a stressful police encounter by lying, but providing false information to law enforcement is a serious crime and in some cases, could even result in felony charges. In this article, our New Jersey defense lawyers will go over New Jerseys laws against lying to police officers, supplying false documents, and interfering with criminal investigations.

    Can I Speak To The Police Off The Record Or Give An Informal Statement

    There is no such thing as off the record with a police officer. Anything you tell a police officer, at any time, can be used against you. It is also important to remember it is not just signed or written statements, or formal audio or videotaped statements, that can be used against you.

    nything you admit to an officer, over the phone or in person, can be instantly recorded by the officer in his or her notebook and used against you at a trial.

    You May Like: When Is Police Shift Change

    Lying To The Police Is It Illegal

    Lets be honestbeing stopped by the police is an intense situation. Regardless of what has happened, there is always an adrenaline rush caused by seeing those blue and red lights directed at you. As the police officer approaches you, its not uncommon for your heart to start racing, your breath to come out rapidly, and for you to forget every sense of normalcy.

    When being questioned by the police, people tend to stutter, slip up, or say the wrong thingeven without meaning to. On the other hand, sometimes people avoid the question or dont answer honestly out of the fear of not being right. In other instances, they may just blatantly lie to cover themselves or to cover someone they know. When people lie to the police it is typically for one of three reasons:

  • The person is guilty of the accused crime and does not want to get arrested.
  • The person is covering up for someone else and doesnt want to be a snitch.
  • The person is worried that the real suspect will retaliate if they found out they snitched.
  • Regardless of the intention, it is never a good idea to lie to the police. Although you do have the right to remain silent, and you have your First Amendment right to freedom of speech, lying to the authorities is a completely different story.

    Filing A False Police Report

    What Happens if You Lie to the Police?

    Every state makes it illegal to file a false police report of a crime. In California, filing a false police report is a misdemeanor offense. Some other states treat it as a felony in some circumstances.

    In Michigan, for example, it is a felony to knowingly make a false report of a crime of terrorism to anyone, including to law enforcement. Convictions carry up to 20 years in prison.6

    Defendants may also be held civilly liable for the costs of law enforcements response to the fake report.

    Read Also: How To Become A Police Sniper

    Can I Lie To The Police

    Interacting with the police can be confusing, frustrating, or outright terrifying. You may know that you have certain rights, like the right to remain silent and the right to an attorney, but how do these apply to your unique situation? What happens if you decide to talk and end up telling a lie to a police officer? In this blog, Ill address what happens if youre accused of lying to the police in Michigan.

    Simply put, you can face criminal charges if you lie to a police officer.

    Michigan Penal Code § 750.479c states that a person who is informed by law enforcement of a criminal investigation cannot: Knowingly and willfully make any statement to the peace officer that the person knows is false or misleading regarding a material fact in that criminal investigation. This also applies to concealing material facts and giving written statements or providing false documents to law enforcement pertaining to a criminal investigation.

    In Michigan, the penalties for lying to the police are as follows:

    Police Officers Not Engaged In Performance Of Lawful Duties

    If the defendant can show that the police officer was not lawfully performing his/her duties at the time of the false representation of identity.

    As discussed above, a police officer is not lawfully performing his/her duty if he/she is unlawfully arresting or detaining someone or using unreasonable or excessive force in his/her duties.

    Read Also: Can I Request A Copy Of My Police Statement

    Why Do People Make False Reports

    People can be tempted to make false reports to the police for a number of reasons. It may be to make up financial loss, for insurance purposes, to avoid other criminal offences or even to avoid getting into trouble with their family or loved ones.

    Examples can include people leaving their vehicles unattended with the keys in the ignition but making a false report as their insurance would not cover them.It can also include children making false reports about crime to avoid getting in trouble with their parents for being late.

    Example Of Presenting A False Identity To A Police Officer:

    Former Willis police officers sentenced after lying about use of force in man’s arrest

    James is pulled over because the police officer suspected that he was driving under influence.

    When the officer asked James for his name, James gave him a name that he made up on the spot.

    James can be charged with the offense because he made up a fake name to avoid presenting accurate identification to the police officer.

    Also Check: How To Become A Desk Police Officer

    Can The Police Lie To You Brief Transcript

    So law enforcement contacts you. Youre down at the station. Youre about to speak to detectives or agents, something youve never done before. So often people ask, can they lie to me? Can they deceive me? Can they mislead me? Can they trick me? My name is Alex Spiro. Im a partner at Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, and Im here to talk to you today about why and under what circumstances law enforcement can lie to you.

    The question here today is can law enforcement lie to a suspect? And the short answer is yes they can. The question at a deeper level is under what circumstances and when? The truth is you do have rights. You dont have to talk to the police at all. If you call the police or they call you and youre not down at the station house, understand that you are not in custody, they do not have to read you Miranda, and your confession or whatever you say to them can be used against you. If you are in custody, they do have to read you Miranda rights, which means you have the right to remain silent. At the end of the day, you can always at any time invoke your right to counsel. Say, I want to talk to my lawyer. It doesnt make you sound guilty its smart. And then they cant question you anymore.

    Is It A Crime To Lie To A Police Officer

    Ronald Hedding

    Its an interesting question because sometimes it is a crime to lie to the police and other times its not a crime to lie to the police. The bottom line is, if the police are trying to question you for some sort of a crime they might think youre involved with, you shouldnt be talking to them.

    Any attorney is going to tell you that. Youre not going to help yourself. Youre not going to out-smart the police. At best, youre going to give you side of the story which will give the prosecutors a chance to use it against you. Remember, youre a target. So, theyre trying to figure out how they can convict you. Another big thing I see when you talk to the police, sometimes they twist your words and say things you didnt say.

    Don’t Miss: What Is The Police Report Number

    False Report Of A Crime

    It is also a criminal offense to make a false report of a crime to law enforcement. In order to be convicted under PC 148.5, the prosecution must prove that you:

    • Knowingly provided a false report that a crime was committed, or
    • Provided false details about a crime that actually was committed

    Examples of this crime include reporting a car stolen when you knew that the car was not stolen or providing a falsely inflated value of the worth of property that actually was stolen.

    What You Need To Know If The Police Want To Speak With You

    Judge Judy: " Lying to a police officer, that is not a ...

    In Canada, you have the right to remain silent. This right is constitutionally protected and enshrined in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. In most cases, you have no obligation to provide any information to the police. There are some exceptions to this rule, however. Here are a few examples:

    • If you are arrested, you must tell the police your name, address, and date of birth.
    • If you are the driver or registered owner a motor vehicle, the Traffic Safety Act requires that you provide information to the police in certain circumstances. For example, the driver of a vehicle involved in an accident is required by law to complete collision statement.
    • If you are participating in a regulated activity the laws and regulations that govern the regulated activity may require you to provide certain information to the investigators or regulators.

    In general, though, you do not need to give the police any information or assist a criminal investigation in any way. If you are unsure about whether you have to cooperate with the police, or how much information you are legally required to give the police, you should always consult with a lawyer. A lawyer can help advise you about what you have to tell investigators , and what information you do not need to provide.

    You May Like: Can You Get A Police Report

    Why Do Police Lie During An Investigation

    Police lie for a number of reasons. The first and most obvious is to create a sense of urgency in a suspect that can promote honesty when they might otherwise withhold information. Beyond that, police officers may say certain things to a suspect in order to build rapport, which means they want the suspects to trust them.

    Lying about what the officer believes happened or what kind of evidence the police have is a common tactic to undermine someones story or get them to comply with the wishes of the police. Although it is against the law for people to give false statements to the police, the same is not true for law enforcement. They can and do lie to both suspects and others during criminal investigations without any sort of consequence.

    Arrested For Lying To Police Officer

    If you have been charged with Lying to a Police Officer in Miami, Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, or Miami Dade County, you should consult an experienced competent criminal defense attorney who can represent you in criminal court. Kenneth P. Hassett of Hassett and Associates, P.A. is a criminal defense attorney who represents clients in Miami, Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Miami Dade County, and the rest of South Florida. Having a criminal defense lawyer to represent you in criminal court is advantageous, especially when charged with serious criminal offenses. Contact Hassett and Associates, P.A. for an immediate free consultation 24 hours per day seven days per week with a criminal defense attorney if you have been charged with these criminal offenses.

    Also Check: How Do Police Investigate Drug Dealers

    This Why You Shouldnt Speak To The Police

    As you can see, there are many different ways you could end up being prosecuted for a crime when you speak to a law enforcement officer. Our law firm strongly recommends that when a police officer wishes to speak to you, do all of the following:

    • Be polite and courteous
    • Provide them with your correct name if requested
    • Provide them with valid identification if asked to do so
    • Provide them with proof of valid car insurance if asked to do so
    • Other than that, do not speak to anyone in law enforcement

    Always politely tell the law enforcement officer that you choose to not answer his or her questions and you wish to speak to your lawyer. If you follow this sound legal advice, you can avoid being accused of providing false information to a law enforcement officer.

    Speak to Our Criminal Defense Attorneys If Youre Accused of Lying to Police

    If you have been charged with lying to a peace officer, you should speak to an experienced criminal defense attorney at Wallin & Klarich as soon as possible. Our skilled criminal defense lawyers have more than 40 years of experience successfully defending clients facing criminal charges for lying to a law enforcement officer. Let us help you now.

    With offices in Orange County, Riverside, San Bernardino, Victorville, West Covina, Torrance, Los Angeles and San Diego, there is an experienced Wallin & Klarich criminal defense attorney available to help you no matter where you are located.

    Why Can Police Lie To You But You Cant Lie To Them

    Jussie Smollett Facing 6 New Charges For Allegedly Lying To Police | TODAY

    When Youre Talking To The Police, Are Police Allowed To Lie To You?

    Police are allowed to lie to you. Again, a lot this comes from watching TV. People think that if you ask an undercover cop if hes a cop, he has to tell you. Thats completely false. If you think about that practically, then everyone would go around anytime they were committing a crime or going to commit a crime and say, Are you a cop? The undercover police system would just completely fail. Police can lie to you, it happens in all different types of ways.

    The police will arrest someone and may lie and say, Oh, weve got your partner in the next room and he is spilling his guts. Now is your time to come clean right now. If you come clean, then were going to be easier on you.

    Well, first of all, the police dont have the power to be easier on you. The prosecutor is who makes the decision on how you will be charged. Law enforcement are actually trained to deceive you to get you to admit to things. Its that kind of attitude that makes people confess to crimes they didnt even commit just because they are so scared of what the police can do to them.

    Another lie that they will tell you is that, Oh, this is off the record. What you are telling me is off the record. Thats also a lie. They are just telling you that they are going to use whatever you say against you later.

    Are You Ever Allowed To Lie To The Police?

    Read Also: How To Be A Dallas Police Officer

    Can You Go To Jail For Lying About A Crime

    A New South Wales court has ruled in favor of a man who sued. When a judicial proceeding is being conducted, perjury is a criminal offence. It involves knowingly making a false statement on oath. Section 327 of the Crimes Act in New South Wales imposes a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison for perjury.

    Your Fingerprints Were All Over The Crime Scene

    Police are permitted to lie about physical evidence that does not exist. For example, the police officers can tell you that they found your DNA or fingerprints crime scene. The truth is that DNA and fingerprints evidence takes substantial time to analyze and process.

    Why do they use this lie? Well, they use the lie to convince you to confess to being at the scene of the crime or to make you give more information that could be helpful to interrogators. The lie can also be used to trick you into surrendering your DNA. Note that if your DNA or fingerprints match what was found at the crime scene, this could be used as evidence that may lead to a conviction.

    Don’t Miss: Can The Police Evict A Tenant

    Laws Against False Incrimination And Lying To Law Enforcement

    New Jersey has adopted several laws which ban different aspects of lying or supplying false information to criminal investigators and police officers. Some of the relevant statutes are summarized below.

    • J.S.A. § 2C:28-4 This statute creates two distinct offenses:
    • Falsely incriminating another person, which means telling an officer that another person committed a crime when they actually didnt. This offense is a crime of the fourth degree, which would be called a fourth degree felony in other jurisdictions.
    • Filing a fictitious police report, which means either reporting a crime despite knowing that such a crime didnt actually occur, or pretending to give a police officer accurate information when the information is actually inaccurate or nonexistent. This offense is graded as a disorderly persons offense, or DP offense, which is roughly equivalent to a misdemeanor in other jurisdictions.

    Find A Tallahassee Defense Attorney

    Lying to a Police Officer Could Result in Criminal Charges ...

    If you or a loved one have been charged with Providing False Information to a Police Officer, your first move should be to reach out to an experienced attorney. In order to receive the best possible advice, it is important to find a team who has the skills and is ready to fight in your corner. Joel Elsea is more than prepared to help with your ongoing case, and to provide you with the top-quality defense your case deserves. If you are in the Leon County or Tallahassee area, reach out to the Pumphrey Law Firm. Dont let one nervous mistake affect your future. today for your free consultation.

    Recommended Reading: How Do I Obtain A Copy Of A Police Report

    More articles

    Popular Articles