Question 3 Of : How Do I Know If My Landline Is Tapped
State Judges Have National Authority And May Order Wiretap On Cell Phones Anywhere In The Country
People v. Schneider
Issue:
Do New York Judges Have National Authority to Wiretap Cell Phones?
Whether a New York State Supreme Court Justice had authority to issue wiretap orders under Title IIIs enabling statute, 18 U.S.C. § 2516, of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968 and under New Yorks CPL article 700.05 on a mobile phones located outside of New York State when all calls originate and terminate outside of New York.
Eavesdropping Warrants are Executed Where and When the Listening Occurs
Holding:
The Court of Appeals held that under both 18 U.S.C. § 2516 and CPL article 700.05, eavesdropping warrants are executed in the geographical jurisdiction where the communications are rerouted, heard, and accessed by authorized law enforcement, and that the Brooklyn Judge, in this case, had jurisdiction to issue to warrant on cell phones in California because, although the calling and receiving cell phones were outside of New York, the calls were rerouted by the phone company to Brooklyn and first listened to in Brooklyn.
Facts:
Analysis:
Interception is not Execution, Listening IsExecution
At issue, in this case, is the interpretation of the statutory language of both Title III of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968 and CPL article 700. Under CPL 700.05, any justice of the supreme court of the judicial district in which the eavesdropping warrant is to be executed is authorized to issue an eavesdropping warrant.
Listening Post Rule
Can Law Enforcement Legally Wiretap Florida Citizens
Under federal law, a legal wiretap requires a court issued wiretap order, or warrant. Because of the solemn protection of individual rights under the Fourth Amendment, this type of order is held to higher standards than other types of warrants.
Before a court will issue a wiretap warrant, Florida law enforcement must prove to the court that there is probable cause justifying the act of tapping someoneâs phone lines. This generally includes convincing the court that by doing so, police will be able to intercept or deter some form of serious crime such as terrorism, murder, kidnapping, drug trafficking, money laundering and various other offenses. In dire cases such as threats to national security, law enforcement may act without first obtaining a warrant.
Wiretap orders may be issued to allow eavesdropping on personal conversations, phone calls and intercepting electronic communications such as email, texting, internet searches and instant messaging. Wiretap orders are limited to certain periods of time and other restrictions.
You May Like: How To Apply For Police Dispatcher
How To Tell If Your Cell Phone Is Tapped In 2022
Technology has been rapidly advancing over the years. Like a double-edged sword, however, technological advancements and innovations have their fair share of advantages and disadvantages. Unfortunately, people always find workarounds to utilize technology for their own personal and/or malicious intentions. Cell phones, for instance, are utilized as gateways to acquire someones confidential information, steal sensitive data, or lure a victim.
Hacking or tapping a cellular phone is one of the most common attacks cybercriminals utilize. Through the use of cutting-edge technology, getting into ones device without having physical access to it has been made easier. In some cases, you wont even notice someone has bugged your cell phone until its too late. To protect or further secure your data from cell phone tapping, here is how to tell if your cell phone is tapped.
You May Be Able To Detect Tracking
An app for Android phones released last week called SnoopSnitch promises to detect whether your phone is being tracked by StingRay-style cell phone surveillance technology. But, as Slate notes, they wont prevent the tracking from taking place. Youll need to turn off your cell phone to do that, and it might help to remove the battery too. Occupy.com, which warned about StingRay surveillance of Occupy protesters, offers some other strategies, such as privacy cases.
Also Check: How To Get Accepted Into The Police Academy
Is The Federal Government Tapping Your Phone
When federal agents show up at your front door during an investigation, they often know quite a bit about you and your case. They may have gone through your bank statements, or even read some of your emails. This often comes as a shock to defendants, and may leave you wondering if the government has been tapping your phone or if they will start. Wiretaps are serious, and often feel like a complete invasion of privacy. If youre under investigation and suspect the government is listening in on your phone calls, reach out to an experienced federal attorney as soon as possible. Your lawyer will help you determine the best course of action and will start building a strong defense to help you avoid a criminal conviction. The sooner you get connected with legal representation, the better your chances are of receiving the best available outcome. Call the Grabel & Associates team right now to get connected with a lawyer who will aggressively fight for you throughout every stage of your case. We can be reached by telephone or via our online contact form 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Your Phone Battery Life Is Always Low
Is your phones battery life low all of the time? Extensive phone use, high screen brightness, multiple applications running, or malfunctioning hardware typically consume a chunk of the phones battery life. A sudden drop in battery percentage could also be triggered by phone tapping. Call recording programs are constantly running in the background, causing the phones battery to get drained easily.
You May Like: How To Become Police Officer Texas
A New Lawsuit Could Shake Loose San Diego Info
Last month, the First Amendment Coalition a California nonprofit devoted to free speech and open government sued the San Diego Police Department and demanded more information about its use of cell phone surveillance technology.
The suit claims that SDPD has denied journalists requests for information about how it uses StingRay devices, and asks the court to compel the city and the police to disclose documents containing information about their possession and use of International Mobile Subscriber Identity Catchers.
Potentially, the lawsuit could turn up details about how the technology is assisting cops. According to Inewsource, the First Amendment Coalition learned that the Los Angeles Police Department used these devices 21 times in a four-month period in 2012 to aid in homicide, kidnapping, suicide, rape, human trafficking, robbery, fugitive and narcotic cases.
Court records indicate that no date has been set for legal proceedings in the lawsuit, which was filed on Dec. 15. The city of San Diego challenged the judge assigned to the case, Richard E. L. Strauss, and the Superior Court transferred the case to Judge Judith Hayes.
When Can New Jersey Police Use Wiretapping
Have you been charged with a crime following a wiretap by law enforcement? New Jersey law enforcement officials possess the power to use wiretaps to monitor and record communication and information sent over a land line phone or cell phone in order to obtain evidence against you in certain situations. However, police must operate under specific guidelines that control and regulate how wiretapping must be conducted. Evidence not procured according to these guidelines can be suppressed . If you have been charged after law enforcement gained information from a wiretap, contact an experienced attorney to protect your rights. The attorneys at Villani & DeLuca in Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey possess the experience and knowledge needed to handle wiretapping and other electronic evidence.
Don’t Miss: How To Get Money Back From Police
Look Through Your Phone
Look through your phone as often as possible from the installed apps to the stored files to the saved photos or videos. Regularly go through each folder and app to ensure there are no unauthorized activities. Make it a habit to check activity or search history especially those that contain sensitive or confidential data. Permanently delete files and apps no longer needed/used. You could also utilize backup and recovery software to easily accomplish these things.
The Right To Tap Your Phone: Pen Registers And Tap And Traces
Two other investigative methods for tapping your phone are “pen registers” and “tap and traces.” Pen registers record all numbers dialed from a particular phone line. Tap and traces record all the numbers that call a particular phone line. Since these only record phone numbers and not the actual conversations, they are considered less of a privacy intrusion and the police do not need to get a wiretap order first.
When police seek a warrant for cellphone data, such as location information to track a person’s whereabouts, separate issues are raised.
Also Check: How Much Do You Make As A Police Officer
How Do The Police Use A Wiretap
The police will utilize the wiretap to listen to your phone discussions with others. There are generally three classifications of calls:
- Class 1 calls are directly related to what the police are investigating.
- Class 2 calls are new crimes that the police did not already know about. These calls usually require the police to return to court and get an amended court order.
- Class 3 calls are junk calls, such as hang-ups.
In addition to listening in on your phone calls, the police can observe your phone calls in other ways. For instance, the police can find out the numbers of everyone who calls you, record your calls, and keep track of all the numbers you call. Whatever the police do, it must be included in the court order.
Consequences Of Failure To Comply With The Act
N.J.S.A. 2A:156A-21 of the law provides that anyone who is injured or negatively effected by an electronic intercept may file a Motion to Suppress the contents of the intercepted wire or communication. There are a variety of grounds upon which failure to adhere to the laws requirements will result in the recording being deemed illegal, including:
- The communication was not obtained in conformity with the Requirements of the Act
- The order authorizing the intercept was defective or insufficient on its face or
- The interception was not obtained in conformity with the Order of Authorization.
If any one or more of the aforesaid grounds exist, the recording was unlawful and cannot be used as evidence against an accused.
Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you were arrested following surveillance of your telephone, cell phone, or text messages. Lawyers are available immediately at 1-877-450-8301 to assist you.
Also Check: How To Become A Police Officer With No Experience
Police Can Tap Your Cell Phone And They Dont Need Anyones Permission
Cell phone monitoring has come a long way since the likes of television shows like The Wire and CSI. But unlike fictional surveillance, some devices currently used by law enforcement dont require a warrant… or any permission at all.
On this weeks episode of 90.5 WESAs Criminal Injustice podcast, host David Harris talks to Adam Bates, who studies the secret use of Sting Ray devices at the Cato Institute in Washington D.C.
Their conversation has been edited for length and clarity.
DAVID HARRIS: What are Sting Ray devices? What do they do?
ADAM BATES: So what it does is simulates the signal of a cell tower and forces the legitimate cell tower signals out and forces any cell phone in the surrounding area to connect to it. And once your cell phone is connected to the Sting Ray, the operator has access to a lot of personal information — not just your phone number but who you’re calling where you are and even the content of your communications.
HARRIS: I could see how these could be very useful for police in finding bad guys more quickly, locating them more precisely, things like that. So they could serve a good law enforcement function, couldn’t they?
HARRIS: Under those agreements, the local law enforcement agency is not allowed to release information about their use or even the existence of the technology.
HARRIS: How widespread is the use of Sting Rays? Federal agencies? State agencies? Both?
HARRIS: Do the police need a warrant?
Other Methods For Tapping A Phone
Law enforcement may also tap your phone using tap and traces or pen registers, which dont require a wiretap order. These methods dont record actual conversations, only the phone numbers associated with the line. Tap and traces record the phone numbers calling a specific phone line. Pen registers record the phone numbers from outgoing calls.
Recommended Reading: How To Get A Police Report From Chp
How Federal Agents Can Tap Your Phones
Letters from the Department of Justice show the FBI tapped both Wichita businessman Brandon Steven and Sedgwick County commissioner Michael O’Donnell’s cell phones in 2015.
Federal agents at the Epic Center won’t say much about why they tapped Steven and O’Donnell, but here’s how the process basically works.
A regular phone call or text message is a conversation between two phones. But when federal agents need to listen in – usually to search for evidence in a crime – they’ll go to a judge and ask for permission to tap your phone.
“Basically, it’s somewhat similar to a search warrant. You have to go to a judge with an affidavit which is a sworn under oath statement of sufficient facts, so that the judge believe there should be a wire tap,” said Charley O’Hara, a criminal defense and federal law attorney.
Judges approving the tap can be local, state, or federal.
“It’s something the judge doesn’t do every day. It’s somewhat unusual, but the judges do them. They do happen,” O’Hara said.
If the judge approves the tap on your cell or landline, here what happens next.
Agents contact the carrier for the phone to be tapped, and all phone calls will be intercepted. A third party can listen in right away, or it can be recorded.
O’Hara says if it’s a cell phone, the tap will probably cover text messages too.
The tap typically lasts for thirty days and after it’s all over, investigators are required by law to tell everyone involved, their conversations were tapped.
Related Stories
What Is The Wiretap Act
The Wiretap Act was initially enacted in 1968 as Title III of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968. Congress passed the legislation after the Supreme Courts decision in Katz v. United States, in which the Court ruled that tapping a phone constituted a search for purposes of Fourth Amendment analysis.
The Wiretap Act prohibits the intentional interception, use, or disclosure of wire and electronic communications unless a statutory exception applies. See 18 U.S.C. § 2511. In general, the Acts prohibitions bar third parties from wiretapping telephones.
However, a wiretap order permits law enforcement officers to intercept wire communications for up to 30 days. See 18 U.S.C. §§ 2516, 2518. A wiretap order must be authorized by the United States Department of Justice and signed by a United States District Court judge or an Appeals judge.
The Wiretap Act imposes significant requirements that must be satisfied before investigators can obtain a wiretap order. Most importantly, the application for a Title III order must show probable cause to believe that the interception will reveal evidence of one of the felony offenses listed in 18 U.S.C. § 2518-.
Read Also: Can The Police Tell If You Have No Insurance
Once Investigators Have Obtained A Wiretap Order
Once investigators have obtained a wiretap order, they must restrict their behavior in order to minimize invasions of privacy. This means that they must adhere to the expiration date of the wiretap order . Also, investigators must limit wiretapping only to phone conversations that are likely to yield evidence against the suspect.
It is important to understand that phone calls made from prison are generally exempt from the wiretap order requirement. Prisoners do not share the same level of privacy that civilians do. They cannot expect that their phone conversations will remain private, and thus investigators typically do not need to ask for permission to record them.
The New York Penal Code governs wiretapping by state investigators. See N.Y. Penal Code §§ 250.00 et seq for more information.